Previous Related Posts:
Was David Miranda a Mule or a Journalist?
Guardian Editor Alan Rusbridger Spins Away
Smashing Hard Drives: the Miranda - Snowden - Guardian Saga Continues
Glenn Greenwald Threatens to spill UK Secrets
UK Detains Greenwald's Partner, Twitter Wars Erupt
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
'Which person,' she [Professor McGonagall] said, her voice shaking, 'which abysmally foolish person wrote down this week's passwords and left them lying around?'
There was utter silence, broken by the smallest of terrified squeaks.
Neville Longbottom, trembling from head to fluffy-skippered toes, raised his hand slowly in the air.
~ from Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, chapter "Flight of the Fat Lady"
From "Extraordinary Court Statement via @davidbarrett and @joshuafoust
- Statement from senior Cabinet Office civil servant to #miranda case says material was 58000 ‘highly classified UK intelligence documents’
- Police who seized documents from #miranda found among them a piece of paper with the decryption password, the statement says
- This password allowed them to decrypt one file on his seized hard drive, adds Oliver Robbins, Cabinet Office security adviser #miranda
- The Govt believes Edward Snowden, the NSA ‘whistleblower’, “indiscriminately appropriated material in bulk” #miranda
- The material contains personal information that would allow British intelligence staff to be identified, inc some overseas, it adds #miranda
- The Govt has had to assume Snowden data is now in the hands of foreign governments, since his travel abroad (to HK and Russia) #miranda
- Statement specifically says UK but they haven’t finish decrypting yet
- It is “impossible” for Glenn Greenwald or any other journalist to determine which info could damage UK national security: Robbins statement
- “The claimant & his associates have demonstrated very poor judgment in their security arrangements with respect to the material…”#miranda
- “…rendering the appropriation of the material, or at least access to it by other, non-State actors, a real possibility” #miranda
- “The fact that…the claimant was carrying on his person a handwritten piece of paper containing the password for one of the encrypted files recovered from him is a sign of very poor information security practice,” says Govt statement #miranda
- Statement implies GCHQ as well as Scotland Yard are working on the electronic media seized from #miranda
From Telegraph UK
David Miranda accused of carrying secrets that threatened spies' lives. This looks bad for Glenn
. . . The Government's accessed just a small portion of an astonishing 58,000 pages of intelligence documents and, according to a witness statement by Oliver Robbins, deputy national security adviser to the Cabinet, it includes: "personal information of UK intelligence officers, any compromise of which would result in a risk to their lives and those of their family members." Robbins argued that if this data had got into the public sphere then it would have made spies and their loved ones vulnerable to attack or recruitment by hostile forces.
. . . Miranda's lawyer said in reply that, "Mr Miranda does not accept the assertions they have made." Presumably, this means that he does not accept the assertion that the data he was carrying threatened UK national security and even the lives of its operatives. Yet this somewhat contradicts something Miranda told The Guardian two weeks ago. Back then, he said, "I don't look at documents. I don't even know if it was documents that I was carrying." So if he didn't look at the documents, how can he know that they didn't include the kind of information that the UK Government alleges?
Anyone claiming that David Miranda was carrying a password that allowed access to documents is lying. UK itself says they can't access them.
— Glenn Greenwald (@ggreenwald) August 30, 2013
@MichaelKelleyBI If they had a password to decrypt, why would they have to "reconstruct" anything? They'd just get right into the docs
— Glenn Greenwald (@ggreenwald) August 30, 2013
@markmcan It didn't allow access to any documents.
— Glenn Greenwald (@ggreenwald) August 30, 2013
@ggreenwald So what did they access in those 20 gigs? What information do they have that allows them to reconstruct?
— Michael Kelley (@MichaelKelleyBI) August 30, 2013
@MichaelKelleyBI Good encryption requires multiple passwords, not just one. That pw allows no access to documents, period.
— Glenn Greenwald (@ggreenwald) August 30, 2013
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
But he's a journo! No, he's family! No, wait, he's...uh... MT @timothy_stanley #Miranda accused of carrying secrets http://t.co/lYdb77ux5Q
— Tom Nichols (@TheWarRoom_Tom) August 30, 2013
Absolutely incendiary report on #Miranda #Greenwald and their crimes. Told you so http://t.co/aykaY5FvDz
— Louise Mensch (@LouiseMensch) August 30, 2013
Confirmed today: Glenn Greenwald is a liar. #Miranda
— Ignacio Carrion (@igcarr) August 30, 2013
So for leaving passwords around, #Miranda now becomes the Neville Longbottom of the #Snowden - #Guardian saga #HarryPotter
— Jeanne K. (@SnarkAmendment) August 30, 2013
@jkfecke @SnarkAmendment @MperiousRex However, I volunteer to send him (and Greenwald and Snowden) the loudest fucking Howler ever made.
— Danielle (@DCPlod) August 30, 2013
@SnarkAmendment I dunno, I think Neville was smarter than that. @amaditalks
— Princess Bitchykins (@SamuraiKnitter) August 30, 2013
Next we’ll find out that the password Miranda had written down was “password”.
— Charles Johnson (@Green_Footballs) August 30, 2013
Well, don't worry. The Russians only got their hands on that data if they were able to crack "password written on paper" technology.
— Jeff Fecke (@jkfecke) August 30, 2013
I'm disturbed that the Media has ceded their role as reporters and as acting as Stenographers for Snowden and Greenwald.
— Malcolm Johnson (@admiralmpj) August 30, 2013
Wait, so Greenwald's partner was traveling with what was basically the NOC list from Mission Impossible when he was detained?
— Ian (@iboudreau) August 30, 2013
"@Green_Footballs: At this point, any journalist who repeats Greenwald’s claims unskeptically is being played for a fool." cc: @chrislhayes
— Scott Finley (@TheScottFinley) August 30, 2013
The UK court ruling shows, once again, how brazenly Greenwald lied about the incident.
— joshuafoust (@joshuafoust) August 30, 2013
Assange, Snowden, Greenwald all traitors that wounded US National Security putting Americans at risk! http://t.co/AjIk8OqMf4
— Frank Beaudine (@usa_truth) August 30, 2013
